professornana (professornana) wrote,

Bully, bully, bully

There are lots of different ways to be a bully. I have known some folks who are straight out aggressive. They confront; they wheedle; they whine. They get their way. However, it is the passive aggressive folks who manage to camouflage bullying so well that sometimes their actions seem reasonable to the outside observer. It seems as though Arne Duncan and some of the other leaders in education at the federal and state and local levels have been using their passive aggressive tactics when it comes to the burgeoning opt out movement.

Here is Arne Duncan's take: "U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan said Tuesday that the federal government is obligated to intervene if states fail to address the rising number of students who are boycotting mandated annual exams."

At the state level?

"State education department spokesman Jonathan Burman said in an email Tuesday that the “the feds are discussing the possibility of imposing penalties for failing to hit participation rate targets.” He added that the state is also expected to “consider imposing sanctions” on districts that fail to meet the 95 percent threshold, which could include withholding money “in the most egregious cases."

And yesterday, the local news indicated Houston ISD might require summer school for those kids who opt out of the state tests.

In an era when parents can opt out of vaccinating their kids, this reaction to opting out of tests seems just a tad, well, over the top. Rather than perhaps reflecting on the reasons why the numbers opting out are growing (and not it is not the suburban Mom syndrome, Mr. Duncan) and what might be done to address those concerns, we are turning to not-so-veiled threats. The threats are wrapped up in terms like the federal government is "obligated" as if there is some sort of mandate to ensure the largest percentage of kids might be made miserable with testing. Or noting that opt out numbers are "egregious." This political speak tells those outside of education that officials know what is best (Father Knows Best, after all, or is it Big Brother?). Those opting out are somehow sabotaging education, making the tests worthless unless 95% of the kids take them (and where does this come from anyway?).

It is time for those in leadership positions to LISTEN to concerns, to RESPOND to those concerns, to ACT without threats.
Tags: bully, opt out, threats

  • Oddly Oz

    Have you missed me? I regret leaving this journal empty for so long. Without going into TMI territory, let's just say that posting was not high on my…

  • Banning books

    Today marks the beginning of Banned Books Week. Each and every year I can recall, there has been some sort of incredible book challenge just as we…

  • Just a little bit, please?

    I am (or was) a diabetic. I now control my numbers through diet. I avoid sweets though I watch jealously as someone enjoys ice cream or cake or both.…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.