professornana (professornana) wrote,
professornana
professornana

School is NOT out for summer

I never had the chance to attend a summer camp when I was a kid. I made sure to remedy that as I was rearing the former residents of the back bedroom. They spent a couple of weeks every summer away from us enjoying the outdoors, meeting new people, learning new things (and I have the lanyards to prove it). Career Girl even spent a summer as a camp counselor. Why am I thinking about summer camps?

A recent link in the NCLE SmartBrief took me to a newspaper report about a summer camp, a very different kind of summer camp: a vocabulary camp intended to raise test scores. You can read the article here: http://tn.chalkbeat.org/2014/06/19/vocabulary-camp-at-sharpe-elementary-keeps-students-focused-on-reading-this-summer/#.U7BBcV5FEdt. I feel so sorry for these kids. Instead of perhaps enjoying time reading for pleasure, they endure vocabulary lessons, read from CCSS books, and basically engage in skill and drill for 6 hours.

All of this teaching in isolation, parsing out words and skills, will not have the same effect if these kids were instead sent home with stacks of books, driven to the public library for story times (they are elementary kids), or had the chances to be in a summer book club where they could read books of interest to them and talk about their reading with others. And just placing the letter "i" in front of a new computer program does not mean that kids are engaged, motivated, or learning.

This morning at the Scholastic Literary Brunch, one of the authors spoke of writing her new novel which she termed as a dytopian novel of the present. I believe that programs like this are that dystopian. Set kids up with programs that track them, drill them with vocabulary out of context. Measure progress on these drills using a computer program and it might appear that there is progress made at least temporarily.

But what happens next? What happens when these kids begin to hate reading even with the bells and whistles of the computer? What happens when next year and the year after that? Are these kids who will develop a love of reading? Kids who will read a book for pleasure? Kids who will get excited about a new book? Somehow I doubt it. In the meantime, monies that could have been spent i=on books, on author visits, on home libraries, on a myriad of things is instead spent doing the same old skill-drill-kill.
Tags: drill, kill, skill
Subscribe

  • And the ALAYMA go to...

    I was up early this morning, so I could set up the computer for the live webcast of the ALA Youth Media Awards. After I did that, I joined in an…

  • ending with a bang not a whimper

    My final duty as outgoing chair of the 2013 Odyssey Committee was to host the awards ceremony yesterday. Before the ceremony, the audio publishers…

  • shooting ourselves in the foot

    Today at ALA in Chicago, the teens came to talk books to the BFYA Committee. There will be some teens attending other functions here as well. Most…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment