professornana (professornana) wrote,
professornana
professornana

  • Location:
  • Mood:

Silly, don't be a hero

Sorry, could not resist the reference in the title of this post.  Maybe later I will be able to come up with a more apt title, but since it is Sunday and our routine takes us off the church, lunch, and errand running, I doubt there will be too much time to reflect on a better title.  But I was thinking about the word "hero" this morning after reading an incredible op-ed piece by Eugene Robinson in today's "Washington Post."  Here is the link:  http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/eugene-robinson-standing-up-for-teachers/2012/09/17/ad3ee650-00fd-11e2-b257-e1c2b3548a4a_story.html

You owe it to yourself to go read it.  Then come on back here.


When I read this piece first thing this morning I was cheered.  There seem to be so few clarion voices talking about teachers.  But then I read this a second time (Close reading, right?) and again.  While I do believe Mr. Robinson is correct about poverty being an oft overlooked factor in education and achievement, I have some reservations about a few things in this editorial.  My gravest comes from the first line:

"Teachers are heroes, not villains, and it’s time to stop demonizing them."


You see, i disagree.  No, I am not saying teachers are villains.  But I do not perceive myself as a hero either.  I am a teacher. I care passionately about students and learning and books and reading.  I teach because it is what I truly believe I was called to do.  Teaching is my vocation not just my job.  But that does not make me a hero.  I think sometimes that we bandy that word about too much: HERO.  When we do that it loses its meaning.  I want to reserve use of hero for those situations when ANYONE acts heroically.  I think of the teacher who lost her job a couple of years ago when she stood up to censors (and I know this is not an isolated incident).  I think of the winner of the NCTE Award for Intellectual Freedom a couple of years ago, a college journalism professor whose students investigated claims by prisoners who felt they had been wrongfully convicted.  His job was threatened; his students were harassed.  I think of the teachers who protected kids during school shootings.  I think of teachers who put their lives at risk educating women or the poor or the outcast  in places around the world.


No, I am not a hero.  They are.  They serve to remind me, though, of the importance of what it is we all do.  Perhaps we are all on a hero's journey, questing after that almost elusive grail, determined to see our way through the challenges. 


And now, let me point out the line in the editorial I loved.  Robinson talks about teachers digging in (referring to the strike in Chicago) and how he might just dig in as well if:  "I were constantly being lectured by self-righteous crusaders whose knowledge of the inner-city schools crisis comes from a Hollywood movie."  NAILED IT!  All too often, I think, those who are critical of education have a Hollywood view of what it is we do.  Teaching is so much more than that. 
Tags: editorials, hero, op-ed, teaching
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment