professornana (professornana) wrote,

  • Location:
  • Mood:

Role of the reviewer

As someone who has had the privilege and responsibility of writing reviews and review columns for quite a few years, there is another facet of #BBW and #SpeakLoudly that needs to be addressed. How much do I reveal in a review without misleading the reader and, at the same time, not causing someone to automatically reject the book because it might be problematic?

I began to think about this one day when someone in a seminar asked me if there was "language" in one of the books I was discussing. Flippant person that I am, I responded that yes, the book was in English. But I knew what this person was driving at immediately. If I responded that in the affirmative, I was fairly certain this person would not even consider purchasing the book. If I lied or hedged, though, was that even worse? Would it be a betrayal? Would this person ever consider a recommendation from me? This is a tightrope that could easily strangle me, I think. What did I do? I answered as honestly as I could about "language."

To be honest, when I read of some of the challenges for "language" I am surprised. I generally cannot recall the use of cussing (dontcha love that word?) unless it seems out of place for the character to use the word. This does not happen often. When a character utters a curse it is generally under the kind of circumstances I would also use more colorful language. One of the books we talked about in class this weekend was Coe Booth's TYRELL. Tyrell uses some colorful language. In his position I would as well. Sometimes a gosh-golly-gee-whiz is insufficient. I have been known to drop the F-bomb in times of great stress. Is this the best way to approach a problem? I am certain it is not. However, I do it. I am all too human. I expect my characters to be human as well.

So, do I tell folks in a review about Operation Be Fucking Normal from the novel I am reviewing? Or do I indicate that there are intense scenes and incredible obstacles for the characters? Yes, there are those little cues we use: intense, mature, etc. Do these alone make someone steer clear of a book? Am I then complicit in the censorship taking place? Sheesh, I really do wish it were more cut and dried than it is.

So, today I finished mailing the last of the banned books out to teachers and librarians. All told, I mailed 20 books. I am taking a couple copies of TWENTY BOY SUMMER and IT'S PERFECTLY NORMAL and ANNIE ON MY MIND to a doctoral seminar in reading tonight where I am speaking about the changing landscape of books and reading. I am sure I will find some other trouble to cause for the final few days of Banned Books Week. For now, I need to get back to the other part of my job--reading and writing about books.

Tags: bbw, censorship, speakloudly

  • Let me do that for you

    Each day I discover that I have won a lottery, that I have been selected to help someone smuggle money out of her country to the US, been told I am a…

  • News we can use

    It is always nice to see a headline declaring problems with CCSS. Here is one from Valerie Strauss of the Washington Post:…

  • O Is for Options

    I am beginning my search for a new car. The one I have is a bit too large for my needs now that College Girl is back at school. And with the soaring…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.